Intermittent Fasting

Intermittent Fasting

The chatter surrounding intermittent fasting has increased signifi-

cantly in the past few years. Not surprisingly, much of the recent

research around fasting and weight loss needs to be more conclu-

sive. What we do know is that long-term studies of intermittent

fasting show links to increased longevity and chronic disease

prevention, but no link to sustainable, long-term weight loss.

Given the benefits, the many options for fasting, and my propen-

sity to experiment on myself, I decided to try a few options to see

the effects.

24-Hour Weekly Fast

I started with a 24-hour fast one time per week for seven weeks.

Difficulty Level:

Very difficult at first to moderate at the end. I fasted from

Wednesday after dinner to Thursday evening, my lighter training

day. My first couple weeks were challenging: low energy on fasting

days, moody and hungry. By the third or fourth week, it got much

easier, and by the end, I could have kept doing it week after week.

It seemed manageable in terms of difficulty.

The Positives:

I learned how to manage hunger. The fasting taught me that it was

okay to be hungry and that I would be okay without having to eat

every two to three hours.

The Negatives:

I didn’t like missing meal times with my family. Sometimes, my 24

hours would fall later than our normal dinner time, and I would

have to just sit at the table without eating. Family meals are big

in our house, and I don’t want to change that part of my lifestyle.

Because my fast days were planned, I also tended to overeat before

and after, and it didn’t feel great to feel stuffed on Wednesday and

Thursday evenings.

12-Hour Daily Fast

For my second experiment, I moved to a 12-hour fast every day

of the week for eight weeks, basically from 8:00 pm after dinner to

8:00 am the next day.

Difficulty Level:

Super easy. I never felt hungry and got into a simple habit of eating

a quick snack at 8:00 am even if I wasn’t hungry, otherwise, I felt

like my training sessions would have been low energy.

The Positives:

I felt great because I never felt hungry. It was easy to manage this

type of fasting and not overeating because I didn’t feel like I was

ever fasting.

The Negatives:

Again, lifestyle! I was missing out on early morning family breakfast

on weekends. We usually wake up and make some kind of banana

bread, muffins, eggs, and turkey bacon. I missed out on that.

16–18-Hour Random Fast

My third experiment was a 16–18 hour fast randomly 3–5 times

per week for four weeks.

Difficulty Level:

Moderately difficult at first, but after about two weeks, I was in a

routine that worked. I would sometimes feel hungry, but not the

kind of hungry that all I could do was think about food.

The Positives:

This fit into my lifestyle. I had the freedom to fast after the last meal

of the day, and the next day, I had a late lunch and that worked well

for me. I never had to miss a family meal, and I had my weekend

early family breakfasts back.

The Negatives:

Some days were tough for me, and when I first started, I tried doing

Monday through Friday fasting for 16–18 hours. Toward the end

of the week, I would get tired or cranky. Also, I didn’t like fasting

on Fridays because we celebrate Shabbat most Fridays, so I do a

lot of cooking during the day, and I don’t like fasting while cooking

all day. Once I adjusted to 3–5 times a week, I had the freedom to

pick my fasting days and make them totally random. This helped

because I didn’t feel like I had to stick to a schedule and it gave me

more freedom.

Now, I follow something close to 3–5 times weekly for 12–18

hours. I like to let it go with where my day is taking me. Since I

have learned to control hunger from the 24-hour fast, I’m okay

with being hungry for a bit. I work best with doing it all randomly.

Big Picture

Fasting can be used for longevity and chronic disease prevention.

Personally, I feel better fasting because it keeps me from being a

late-night snacker. I slept better not going to bed feeling full and

I liked waking up feeling lighter and more energetic. But the jury

is still out on intermittent fasting. There is not a lot of conclusive

science that backs up any method in terms of longevity and weight

loss. However, I have seen intermittent fasting used very success-

fully as a tool to create some boundaries and guidelines for people

who are trying to create better nutrition habits around things

like eating later or snacking while watching TV late at night. The

no-eating time creates some clarity and sets clear boundaries on

exactly when you can and can’t eat. But no one method works for

everyone.

If you are interested, experiment with several methods to see

what works best for you. Women who are over 40 may want to

be more strategic about intermittent fasting. Restricting calories

when training can affect energy levels and performance during

training, especially when trying to build lean muscle and increase

hormones. Some women who have practiced intermittent fasting

have noticed an increase in metabolism and a decrease in body

fat. It all depends on genetics, fitness level, health, lifestyle, etc.

As always, if you experience any abnormal symptoms like depres-

sion, nausea, dizziness, or, even in some cases, body swelling, you

should stop fasting and consult a doctor.

See you in the gym,

Aaron Leventhal CSCS, PN1, ACSM Cancer Specialist

Next
Next

80 percent rule